Best for: Readers who want to see which evidence gaps still limit Irri Hub technical guidance.
These gaps remain open until the supporting source or review has been checked and recorded. Finding a possible source or saving a draft does not close an evidence gap.
Open evidence
- Earlier evidence files: some controlled source material has not been located. Material that depends on it must not be treated as fully reviewed.
- Independent review: no named reviewer, scope, findings, decision or review date is recorded for the complete engineering set.
- Historic equation locations: the original Colebrook equation typography and the relevant 1845 Weisbach equation typography have not been visually verified. For Colebrook, the current publisher record confirms the original paper, issue, pages and DOI, while a non-publisher searchable scan reproduction text-locates the transition-formula discussion and equations (10)–(13), including formula (12), to printed page 140. That narrows the page locator but does not close the publisher-authentication or visual equation check. For Weisbach, the first-edition primary text places the pipe-flow chapter from printed page 421, section 329 at pages 431–432, sections 330–331 at pages 433–434, and section 332 at pages 435–436. No historical formula has been transcribed or claimed verified; S17 remains the separate Colebrook correspondence.
- Pipe roughness benchmark: the tenfold roughness mismatch on Penn State PDF pages 4–5 was visually confirmed in the recorded source audit. That worked example remains excluded. Separate synthetic arithmetic checks are recorded, but do not establish product roughness or resolve the conflicting example.
-
EPANET formula presentation: current EPA online sections 3.1 and 12.1 were checked separately from archived section 13.1, printed pages 111–112. The official EPA archive has a recorded release identity (tag 2.2.0, commit
6d7f5f9c08048ce6b25bb64340547446362ec389), a public solver locator (SRC_engines/src/solver/hydcoeffs.c, functionsDWpipecoeff()andfrictionFactor()) and a current manual-source locator (User_Manual/docs/12_analysis_algorithms.rst). The current rendered section and its repository source agree on the laminar Re < 2,000, turbulent Re > 4,000 and transition 2,000 < Re < 4,000 boundaries, the 0.25-over-log-squared Swamee-Jain presentation and the nestedX4transition expression. This closes the current-document location/presentation subgap only. A bounded official repository/documentation check on 25 October 2026 did not locate a standalone erratum for the packaged static 2.2.0 PDF, so its visually confirmed logarithm/regime-wording issues remain a static-PDF hold; no reproducible-binary audit or line-by-line reconciliation is established. Exact archived equation transcription remains withheld, and the Swamee-Jain approximation must remain distinct from an iterative Colebrook solution. - Product-specific data: there is no reviewed automatic water-property service, approved product-specific roughness dataset or complete released hydraulic chain. Do not treat the current material as an automatic capacity, pipe-size or product recommendation.
- Presentation and accessibility: complete desktop, mobile, keyboard, screen-reader and independent technical checks remain outstanding where stated.
- Pump suction and NPSH: the public Hydraulic Institute explanation of the 2024 guideline has been checked. The complete standard tables, exact pump NPSHR curve and revision, system NPSHA across the operating range, liquid properties, datum and selected margin remain open for every real application. The older DOE 25% rule is not a universal publication default.
- Intake and water quality: England eel-screen guidance, a broad 2005 fish-screening guide and horticultural water-quality guidance have been checked. Actual licence conditions, UK jurisdiction, ecological assessment, clean/fouled screen loss, laboratory brief, source variation and crop/turf/equipment acceptance limits remain site-specific.
- Source and storage decision: general BGS, Environment Agency and Water Regulations evidence has been checked. Actual borehole/source time series, pumping test, licence, demand profile, time-step balance, pump curves, quality and controls remain open for every project.
- Tank quotation and installation: general access, turnover, physical separation, overflow and warning topics have been checked; structural support is still an unresolved design requirement. Exact manufacturer instructions, structural/base design, usable volume, connection loads, local water-undertaker decision, electrical design and commissioning acceptance remain project-specific.
- RBY pressure-loss source data: Rain Bird's current official product pages, rechecked 25 October 2026, supply usable named-model operating ranges for RBY075MPTX, RBY100MPTX, PRF-075-RBY and PRF-100-RBY. The current Inline RBY page still embeds Rain Bird's 2018 pressure-loss chart image, whose inline-filter table retains the same inconsistent flow-unit pairings as the linked PDF. The issue is therefore not confined to an old detached download. A bounded official-source search did not locate a corrected exact-model table. Inline pressure-loss rows remain withheld until corrected manufacturer data is matched to the exact model, screen and document edition. Do not substitute the separate PRF table or silently realign the printed columns.
Resolved source-access gap
NRCS Pipe Flow — checked 16 October 2026: the full NEH Part 634, Chapter 4, first edition February 2022, was retrieved and relevant pages visually inspected. The earlier complete-file retrieval limit is resolved. Exact section locations are recorded as S46 in Technical Sources, and two isolated arithmetic comparisons are recorded in the Verification and Test Record. The separate Irrigation Pipeline conveyance standard remains a different source. UK applicability, product-specific inputs, complete calculation validation and independent technical review remain separate requirements.
Effect on the guidance
Where a gap affects a calculation or recommendation, the affected result should be withheld or clearly limited. Closing one gap does not automatically resolve another.
How evidence is closed
The record should identify the source, exact location, checked state, effect on the guidance and any changed revision. Preference is given to publishers, government bodies, standards organisations, universities and accountable library records. Search snippets and unattributed copies may help locate a source but are not final evidence.