A sand separator and a media filter do different jobs. A hydrocyclonic separator removes suitably dense particles by centrifugal action; a media filter captures material through a depth bed. Neither replaces final filtration unless the design proves it.
Choose from the contaminant
| Device | Useful for | Key limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Hydrocyclonic separator | Sand or grit appreciably denser than water, at a flow within the rated operating range. | Does not reliably remove floating organics, dissolved minerals or particles with density close to water. |
| Media filter | Depth filtration of difficult surface water, algae/organic loading and precipitated material when the media is selected for it. | Requires correct media, bed condition, backwash flow and waste handling. |
| Screen or disc after-filter | Final protection and evidence of downstream particle control. | Can block rapidly if upstream treatment is inadequate. |
Sizing evidence
- Particle-size and suspended-solids information from representative sampling.
- Minimum, normal and maximum flow through each vessel.
- Permitted pressure loss and minimum pressure for backwash.
- Number of vessels online during backwash.
- Purge or sludge volume, discharge route and access for inspection.
Netafim's SandStorm guidance identifies surface water, organic matter, silt/clay and iron-related duties for specific media-filter arrangements. Rain Bird's filtration design guide includes separators, suction screens and automatic filtration layouts.
Commissioning
Record inlet/outlet pressures, flow, separator purge behaviour, media depth and grade, backwash expansion or manufacturer checks, clean differential pressure and final-filter condition. Inspect captured material to confirm the treatment train is removing the expected contaminant.
Safety boundary: vessels and purge lines contain pressure and moving water. Isolate, depressurise and control contaminated discharge before opening or servicing.
Assumption and limitation: “sand filter” is ambiguous and may mean a separator or a media vessel. Confirm the device and performance data rather than relying on the name.
Related: intakes and screening and filter sizing.